Skip to main content

How can I Prove or Disprove a Statement?

 Problem-Solving: Disproving  or Proving a Statement

There are several strategies to demonstrate the falsity of a statement:

  • Contradiction: If a statement directly conflicts with a well-established fact or theory, it can be considered false. However, this is not an infallible test, as groundbreaking theories often challenge existing paradigms.
  • Expert Opinion: While relying on experts can be helpful, it's not definitive. Even experts can be mistaken.
  • Personal Belief: Personal beliefs, especially without a strong logical foundation, are unreliable for determining truth.
  • Logical Falsification: In fields like mathematics and science, proving the conclusion of a statement false through accepted logical methods can be a strong indicator of its overall falsity.
  • Lack of Replicability: If a statement or experiment cannot be replicated, it raises doubts about its validity.
  • Author's Reputation: If the author has a history of making false or misleading statements, it can cast doubt on their claims.
  • False Premises: If one or more of the underlying assumptions (premises) of a statement is false, the entire statement can be considered false. This is akin to the “straw man” fallacy, wherein the statement is distorted to the point where the statement becomes or appears to be false.   

Establishing the Truth of a Statement

Conversely, here are some ways to establish the truth of a statement:

  • Expert Authority: Relying on the expertise of credible individuals can be a useful approach.
  • Consistency: If a statement aligns with other accepted truths, it can strengthen its credibility.
  • Logical Proof: In fields like science, a rigorous logical proof can verify the truth of a statement.
  • Legal Authority: In legal contexts, the ruling of a higher court can establish the truth of a statement or decision.
  • Personal Belief: While personal belief can be a factor, it's often unreliable without supporting evidence.

A Note on Absolute Truth:

It's important to note that absolute truth is a complex concept, often elusive outside of specific domains like mathematics. Many statements can be considered true or false based on context, evidence, and perspective.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Please Comment.

Popular posts from this blog

Behavioral Science and Problem-Solving

I.                                       I.                 Introduction.                Concerning our general behavior, it’s high about time we all had some understanding of how we operate on ourselves, and it is just as important how we are operated on by others. This is the wheelhouse of behavioral sciences. It is a vast subject. It touches our lives constantly. It’s influence is pervasive and can be so subtle we never notice it. Behavioral sciences profoundly affect our ability and success at problem-solving, from the elementary level to highly complex wicked problems. This is discussed in Section IV. We begin with the basics of behavioral sciences, Section II, and then through the lens of multiple categories and examples, Section III. II.     ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Principles of Insufficiency and Sufficiency

   The principles we use but don't know it.  1.      Introduction . Every field, scientific or otherwise, rests on foundational principles—think buoyancy, behavior, or democracy. Here, we explore a unique subset: principles modified by "insufficiency" and "sufficiency." While you may never have heard of them, you use them often. These terms frame principles that blend theory, practicality, and aspiration, by offering distinct perspectives. Insufficiency often implies inaction unless justified, while sufficiency suggests something exists or must be done. We’ll examine key examples and introduce a new principle with potential significance. As a principle of principles of these is that something or some action is not done enough while others may be done too much. The first six (§2-6) of our principles are in the literature, and you can easily search them online. The others are relatively new, but fit the concepts in the real world. At times, these pri...
Post a Comment
Read more

Fake News

If you've been following the news the last couple of days, you will note the flurry of copy devoted to fake news.  Both sides are blaming whatever has befallen them the consequence of fake news.  Let's look at this phenomenon a bit.    When I was a student years ago, a friend climbed some mountain in Peru.   A article was written in the local newspaper about the event.   In only three column inches, the newspaper made about six errors.   An easy article to write you say?   Just interview and reproduce.   Yet so many errors?   The question is this: was this fake news or bad reporting?   The idea here is that fake news comes in various flavors. Bad reporting – errors made by the author or editor Opinion presented as news     Deliberate creation of falsehoods to favor a point of view       The reporting of selected truths to favor a particular point of view Now we have the big social media ...
Post a Comment
Read more