Critical Analysis of Books and Journal Articles
Unless you are an expert in the subject, you are often left with no
choice but to accept the information presented and attempt to understand it.
Critical analysis, particularly in technical fields, is not something everyone
can easily engage in; it takes years of experience to develop the necessary
expertise. Readers should assume that articles are written and reviewed by
experts, with the expectation that both processes are conducted in good faith.
This forms the credibility of the sources.
When encountering new or unvetted material, skepticism is
warranted, but true critical analysis is typically beyond the capacity of
students or amateurs. While there are rare exceptions, they are uncommon. If
the material you're reading is primarily opinion-based, it’s important to
approach it with a healthy level of skepticism. However, you must also ask
yourself whether you possess the expertise to confidently reject the claims
being made. If you challenge the material by relying on personal beliefs, you risk
creating a dilemma, but this is not genuine critical analysis.
Comments
Post a Comment
Please Comment.