Skip to main content

Advice: To Give or Not To Give

 As social people, we love to give advice. “You should do this.” “You shouldn’t do that.” “The prof’s an easy grader. Just study the worksheet.” “You should buy that car.” But do you ever know all the facts? Do you see only a simplified situation with essential facts removed? Is your friend asking for advice or asking for hope? There’s a difference.  Hope is the meta-fuel of well-being, giving comfort and peace in times of distress. Is your friend asking for the advice they want to hear? For something they’ve considered but needs confirmation? For a go-sign?

We, the advice-givers, all too often venture into homespun psychology. Not good,
mostly because we don’t know any.

Among the biggest advice-givers are friends, parents, pastors, and teachers. For younger persons, parental advice is often rejected, but the other three are on the spot.  Because, if they give advice, they must accept some responsibility if it is accepted. The pastor hopefully limits advice to simple homilies on living or church teachings. Teachers are safe if the advice is about the course. Friends are the most liable of all. They shovel it out by the carload and it’s hardly limited by knowledge.

One problem with giving advice is you must accept some responsibility if it’s taken.

As a teacher and administrator, I’m asked for advice all the time. Often, the student is not doing well, and just as often it is because the student doesn’t study enough. What I usually do is simply talk the student into discovering their own problems and resolving them. Do you study enough? Do you come to class? Did you buy the book? Did you go to the help session? And so on… As instructors, we are advised by trained counselors not to give personal advice. It’s risky, even libelous. Students are often personally troubled by problem-types we have long forgotten.

Should you give advice? It’s a judgment call, but you can be just a friend, pastor, or teacher and offer some comfort, maybe a little tough love, or suggest self-reflection. After all, if they’re smart enough to be your friend, they’re smart enough to think things through.

If you’re a parent, I feel your pain.  As a commencement speaker recently said to the new grads, “I have lots of advice to give you; my kids didn’t take any of it.”

Don’t be like Aunt Syl in the film This Happy Breed, 1949, who lives only to give critique and advice to everyone, even those not listening.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Please Comment.

Popular posts from this blog

Behavioral Science and Problem-Solving

I.                                       I.                 Introduction.                Concerning our general behavior, it’s high about time we all had some understanding of how we operate on ourselves, and it is just as important how we are operated on by others. This is the wheelhouse of behavioral sciences. It is a vast subject. It touches our lives constantly. It’s influence is pervasive and can be so subtle we never notice it. Behavioral sciences profoundly affect our ability and success at problem-solving, from the elementary level to highly complex wicked problems. This is discussed in Section IV. We begin with the basics of behavioral sciences, Section II, and then through the lens of multiple categories and examples, Section III. II.     ...
Post a Comment
Read more

UNCERTAINTY IS CERTAIN

  Uncertainty is Certain G. Donald Allen 12/12/2024 1.       Introduction . This short essay is about uncertainty in people from both secular and nonsecular viewpoints. One point that will emerge is that randomly based uncertainty can be a driver for religious structure. Many groups facing uncertainty about their future are deeply religious or rely on faith as a source of comfort, resilience, and guidance. The intersection of uncertainty and religiosity often stems from the human need to find meaning, hope, and stability in the face of unpredictable or challenging circumstances. We first take up the connections of uncertainty to religion for the first real profession, farming, noting that hunting has many similar uncertainties. Below are groups that commonly lean on religious beliefs amidst uncertainty.   This short essay is a follow-up to a previous piece on certainty (https://used-ideas.blogspot.com/2024/12/certainty-is-also-emotion.html). U...
Post a Comment
Read more

Robin Hood and Cliven Bundy

  Actor Herbert Mundin, playing Munch in the 1938 film The Adventures of Robin Hood (starring Errol Flynn) is charged by Prince John's troops of slaying a royal deer in the royal Sherwood forest.  The punishment is death.  Though the events of this film are a portrayal of events dating to the 15th century, they became by the 19th century a "robbing from the rich for the poor" theme so often depicted in other film genres. The William Tell legend is another. The plot is simple.  A poor man desperate to survive tastes the forbidden fruits owned by the authority, and is condemned. I would love to hear this event debated on the current TV news shows.  On the one hand, Munch would be a champion in service to his family.  On the other hand, his legal rights are restricted by legal authority. so, the argument would proceed.  Legal scholars cite statutes chapter and verse, while others would root for the common man.  Fast forward to 2014. Parallels ...
Post a Comment
Read more