Skip to main content

To Solve a Problem - Part II

Thanks for all the superb comments.

Indeed, it is noted that the heavyweights have been mentioned, notably Poincare, Hadamard, Archimedes, and others. The great Albert Einstein, who used thought experiments to both pose and then solve problems should be included. These were the true problem creators and solvers in history.  History is dotted with great problems solvers in almost every genre, though their methods were not always known.  When the "prince" of mathematicians, Johann Carl Friedrich Gauss (1777 – 1855) , was asked why it was unclear how he constructed his marvelous solutions and theories, he responded that he wished not to leave the scaffolding apparent.

Henry James (1843 –  1916), an American philosopher, anticipated some of this with his pragmatic philosophy by which the solution (i.e. recourse) that works is the solution to accept.  Let me sketch a bit on problems, pre-problems, solutions, sub-solutions, pre-solutions, and problem determination. From these, a suggested checklist might evolve. Yet, forming a checklist combines both a problem and a solution in the meta-sense.

On Problems
  • Some problems come to us delivered, wrapped up as it were and clear, seeking a solution. Rules are unmitigated.
  • Some problems come to us as situations, not with a clear problem defined, but needing clarity. Here the task is problem formulation, and with that an accepted formulation.
  • Some problems come as questions, wherein the solver is relegated to the task of giving an answer. Many of these have no solution.
  • Some problems are fundamentally semantic, and devolve into issues of our highly flawed language. (Logicians work this end of the street. Demagogues uses these for political points.)
On Solutions.
  • There is but one solution, as the problem is clearly defined.
  • Some solutions offer only partial resolution and then only to those with this particular view. Often there are contradictory alternative solutions.
  • Some problems have only incomplete solutions, in some cases a solution to a substantial but only partial, or sub-problem. Such really difficult problem solutions are developed in this manner. A normal pattern, this is. E.g. Fermat's theorem, and the Poincare conjecture - now theorem. This engenders the idea of solution evolution.
  • Some problems have multiple solutions, each admirable in and of itself, but each incomplete, possible due to incomplete or very low information.
  • Some solutions require true innovation. Such require the inclusion of new and different problem solutions, and new ideas.
  • Some solutions involve the psychological, the logical, the pragmatic, the philosophical, the intuitive, the programmatic, and even the sociological aspects of the multi-faceted manner(s) in which we think. See http://used-ideas.blogspot.com/2013/02/problem-solving-your-marvelous-brain.html

I know these lists are incomplete but am hoping they illustrate the complexity. It is difficult for me to see a seminal work arising from this contradictory, and conflicting melee of possibilities.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

UNCERTAINTY IS CERTAIN

  Uncertainty is Certain G. Donald Allen 12/12/2024 1.       Introduction . This short essay is about uncertainty in people from both secular and nonsecular viewpoints. One point that will emerge is that randomly based uncertainty can be a driver for religious structure. Many groups facing uncertainty about their future are deeply religious or rely on faith as a source of comfort, resilience, and guidance. The intersection of uncertainty and religiosity often stems from the human need to find meaning, hope, and stability in the face of unpredictable or challenging circumstances. We first take up the connections of uncertainty to religion for the first real profession, farming, noting that hunting has many similar uncertainties. Below are groups that commonly lean on religious beliefs amidst uncertainty.   This short essay is a follow-up to a previous piece on certainty (https://used-ideas.blogspot.com/2024/12/certainty-is-also-emotion.html). U...

Problem Solving? Then Find Those Gaps

  Problem Solving - Finding Gaps 12/28/2024 Introduction. Solving complex problems often arises from the presence of gaps in knowledge, resources, understanding, or perspectives. These gaps introduce uncertainty, ambiguity, or constraints, making solutions difficult to achieve. Below, we explore the primary types of gaps that complicate problem-solving and their implications. Many are of the technical, informational, theoretical, and social nature. You may discover some of these gaps are also sources of uncertainty in problem-solving, in that they supply us with another list of things that can go wrong based on something missing. Gaps also form a type of impossible problem, that will be discussed in a later chapter. Finally, this essay is about all problems and solutions, not just those of science. Contents Comprehension Gaps Consistency Gaps Solution-Type Gaps Invisible Gaps   Knowledge and Evidence Gaps   Methodological and Technological Gaps Ethical and Cult...

CERTAINTY IS ALSO AN EMOTION

  Certainty is also a Feeling Certainty is often viewed as a mental state tied to knowledge and confidence, but it also functions as a feeling with distinct emotional and physiological components. While it arises from cognitive processes, certainty also has a subjective and emotional quality that makes it more than just a rational judgment. It provides a sense of assurance and security that shapes human experience in profound ways. Emotional Dimension . At its core, certainty evokes emotions that influence how we perceive and interact with the world. When someone feels certain, they often experience relief, comfort, or empowerment. These emotions are particularly strong when uncertainty or doubt is resolved, offering a sense of closure. For example, solving a complex problem or having a belief validated by evidence brings not just intellectual satisfaction but also emotional reassurance. Subjectivity. Certainty is inherently personal and subjective. It depends on individual...