Skip to main content

Can Online Education Work?

We are talking about the future of education on this planet.  It may be worth a few moments' consideration.
------------

Can Online Education Work?  Well, can it?  We are discussing here the future of education on this planet.  Here are a few notes about online learning that may be of interest.  I know the faculty is generally dead-against it, but it is coming, maybe like a plague, maybe like salvation. 'Tis a juggernaut.   It is incumbent upon schools and colleges to make it work.  Administrators think of dollars, faculty think of self-interest.  Compromise is needed.
--------------
Online education is here, and it is here to stay.  Many issues, particularly costs, mandate continuance of this new venue.  I'm for it, make no doubt.  But we must be at least a little critical.  So, I mention a few factors, mostly technical with the title, "What is wrong with online education?"  Here are a few factors that speak against the purely online format, bare and un-enhanced.

1. Sociability. Students need to work together in a collective way, exploring new ideas, challenging or agreeing on premises, clarifying key or muddy points, reflecting with colleagues on the day's work, working with colleagues on assignments - not to cheat but to consider and enhance meaning. This is just like in my college days.  Online learning creates or is sustained in a venue of isolation.

2. Multiple channels of learning.  The traditional lecture is not all that bad, though it has obvious defects.  Boring, or poor presentations, unsuitable class times and sizes are just a few.  One true values of the lecture is in the note-taking of students.  Why? Because note taking stimulates at least two channels of memory, writing (tactile) and hearing.  Also, and this is most important to some, there is the visual impact of the physical presence of the professor giving the lecture. This should be concatenated with actually "being there." Singularly, this has high learning value.  Online learning gives only a rather passive environment. 

3. Spatial.  The constant spatial location of the lecture gives a type of constancy of the learning.  When in the classroom, the student is tuned to the environment and learns partly in that context.  This is not to diminish independent learning outside the classroom, but is yet another factor to consider.  When someone learns at home or wherever, this essential factor is diminished. Spatial effects and even odor have been connected with permanence of memory.

While online learning can deliver content, we ask: Can it deliver the critical values students learn from the social, multiple channels of learning, and spatial effects so important to sustained memory and long term recollection?  For online learning to be successful, it must address these points.  Are chat rooms enough?  Are YouTube videos enough?  We know nothing beyond anecdotal examples.  Can online learning be better?  Will it be worse?  We don't know. It is important to be mindful of the admonition by Lee Shulman,
past president of the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching, who gives us, The plurality of anecdote does not equal evidenceResearch needs to be carried out on the "permanence of learning" in the new online world. 

In all of this, we ignore the obvious and rampant aspects of online cheating -  a growing concern.

http://used-ideas.blogspot.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

UNCERTAINTY IS CERTAIN

  Uncertainty is Certain G. Donald Allen 12/12/2024 1.       Introduction . This short essay is about uncertainty in people from both secular and nonsecular viewpoints. One point that will emerge is that randomly based uncertainty can be a driver for religious structure. Many groups facing uncertainty about their future are deeply religious or rely on faith as a source of comfort, resilience, and guidance. The intersection of uncertainty and religiosity often stems from the human need to find meaning, hope, and stability in the face of unpredictable or challenging circumstances. We first take up the connections of uncertainty to religion for the first real profession, farming, noting that hunting has many similar uncertainties. Below are groups that commonly lean on religious beliefs amidst uncertainty.   This short essay is a follow-up to a previous piece on certainty (https://used-ideas.blogspot.com/2024/12/certainty-is-also-emotion.html). U...

CERTAINTY IS ALSO AN EMOTION

  Certainty is also a Feeling Certainty is often viewed as a mental state tied to knowledge and confidence, but it also functions as a feeling with distinct emotional and physiological components. While it arises from cognitive processes, certainty also has a subjective and emotional quality that makes it more than just a rational judgment. It provides a sense of assurance and security that shapes human experience in profound ways. Emotional Dimension . At its core, certainty evokes emotions that influence how we perceive and interact with the world. When someone feels certain, they often experience relief, comfort, or empowerment. These emotions are particularly strong when uncertainty or doubt is resolved, offering a sense of closure. For example, solving a complex problem or having a belief validated by evidence brings not just intellectual satisfaction but also emotional reassurance. Subjectivity. Certainty is inherently personal and subjective. It depends on individual...

Lies, Deceit, and the National Agenda

The world you grew up in is no more.  The world of reasonable honesty and reasonable lies has been replaced by abject dishonesty and blatant lies. Lies.  Yes. People have always told them.  You have told them; so have I.   We need lies; they are a foundational structure of social living.  They both deceive and protect.  Children tell them to their parents to avoid consequences, like punishment.  Adults tell them to their bosses, to enhance their position and/or avoid consequences of poor performance.  Our bosses tell them to their boards to suggest business is good, the project is on target, or the detractors are wrong.  The boards tell them to shareholders to protect their own credibility and most importantly, stock values.   Our politicians tell lies to their constituents, though sometimes innocently with them not actually knowing much more than they've been told.  They enhance their positio...